LLC vs. S Corp: Which One Is Right for Your Business?

Summary of What This Blog Covers:

• Compare the differences between an LLC and an S Corporation to determine which structure is right for your business: This blog breaks down how each impacts your taxes, self-employment obligations, and administrative requirements, helping business owners understand when to stick with a simple LLC and when it’s time to consider S Corp status.
  
  
• Learn how S Corp status can reduce self-employment taxes and when it actually adds cost: From paying yourself a reasonable salary to managing payroll and filing Form 1120-S, you’ll get a real-world look at how S Corps save money when your business is ready, and when they become a financial burden if elected too early.
  
  
• Understand key compliance responsibilities and IRS expectations for S Corporations: The blog walks through everything from running payroll and issuing W-2s to handling 1099 NEC forms, FBAR filing, and avoiding costly mistakes that often arise after electing S Corp status.
  
  
• Explore alternatives and get expert support from a CPA firm in Austin, Texas: Whether you’re not ready for an S Corp or you’re unsure what structure makes sense, Insogna CPA offers personalized entity evaluations, Form 2553 filing, tax planning, and full compliance support to help business owners grow with confidence.

Real Talk About Taxes, Take-Home Pay, and When to Make the Switch

Let’s take it back for a second.

You launched your business with a dream and a domain name. You chose “LLC” because, well, it seemed simple. Fast forward, and now you’re making real money. Your business is growing, your tax bills are growing, and you’re hearing a lot of buzz about switching to an S Corporation to “save on taxes.”

Maybe your friend said it. Maybe your accountant hinted at it. Maybe you’ve been Googling “tax preparer near you” at 11 p.m., wondering if you’re missing out on something big.

Before you file Form 2553 and switch your entity type, take a deep breath.

At Insogna CPA, a top-rated Austin Texas CPA firm, we’ve helped hundreds of business owners navigate this exact question:

Is it time to stay the course with your LLC, or are you ready to graduate to an S Corp?

Let’s dig into the details. This blog will help you understand when switching to an S Corp is the move, and when it just adds more headaches (and higher accounting fees).

LLC vs. S Corp: Why This Choice Matters

Choosing the right business structure isn’t just a legal formality, it impacts your:

• Taxes
  
  
• Liability
  
  
• Payroll responsibilities
  
  
• Recordkeeping
  
  
• Compliance load
  
  

The good news? Both LLCs and S Corps offer liability protection and pass-through taxation. But they come with very different compliance rules, tax strategies, and levels of effort.

Whether you’re just starting out or you’re a six-figure solopreneur, understanding the LLC vs. S Corporation breakdown is crucial.

Let’s Define the Terms

• An LLC (Limited Liability Company) is a legal entity formed at the state level.
  
  
• An S Corp is a tax classification granted by the IRS to an LLC or C Corp after filing Form 2553.
  
  

S Corp status changes how your profits are taxed but it doesn’t change your LLC’s legal structure. It’s an election, not a new company.

If you’re unsure whether an LLC or S Corp works best for your goals, a licensed CPA or tax advisor in Austin can help analyze your financials.

LLC vs. S Corp: Quick Comparison

Why Most Start with an LLC

An LLC is a low-maintenance starting point. It gives you:

• Personal liability protection
  
  
• Pass-through taxation
  
  
• No payroll requirements
  
  
• Flexibility to reinvest profits
  
  

When an LLC Makes the Most Sense:

• Your net income is under $50K
  
  
• You’re still building steady revenue
  
  
• You prefer simplicity over compliance
  
  
• You’re not ready to run payroll or file corporate returns
  
  

If you’re searching “small business CPA Austin” or “tax consultant near me” because your profit is rising but you’re not sure if it’s time to switch. We’ll help you compare, side-by-side.

When an S Corp Starts Making Sense

The biggest draw of an S Corporation? Self-employment tax savings.

Sole proprietors and LLC members pay 15.3% self-employment tax on all net profit. But S Corp owners only pay those taxes on their W-2 salary. The remaining profit, taken as distributions, isn’t taxed for Social Security or Medicare.

Real Example:

You earn $100K in net profit.

• As an LLC: You pay 15.3% on all $100K = $15,300.
  
  
• As an S Corp: Pay yourself a $50K salary (taxed normally), take the remaining $50K as distributions (not taxed for SE tax).
  Savings: ~$7,650.
  
  

When It’s Time to Consider an S Corp:

• Your net profit is $50K+
  
  
• You can justify a reasonable salary
  
  
• You’re ready for payroll, tax filings, and recordkeeping
  
  

A qualified Austin TX accountant or tax professional near you can help assess your situation.

But Wait, S Corps Have Their Own Costs

Here’s where entrepreneurs often get caught off guard. S Corps save on taxes but they come with added complexity and cost.

Required for S Corps:

• W-2 payroll (even if you’re the only employee)
  
  
• Payroll provider fees
  
  
• Quarterly payroll tax filings (Form 941, state forms)
  
  
• Form 1120-S (your separate business return)
  
  
• W-2 and 1099 filings
  
  
• Annual compliance documentation (bylaws, minutes, etc.)
  
  

Cost Estimate:
 You could spend $1,500–$3,000+ annually on payroll processing, CPA fees, and compliance filings.

Still think you’re ready? Let a certified CPA near you break it down.

The Key to S Corp Success: Reasonable Salary

Here’s where a lot of S Corps get tripped up: owners try to pay themselves next to nothing and take the rest in distributions.

Bad idea.

The IRS requires you to pay a reasonable salary before taking distributions.

What’s “Reasonable”?

• Comparable to others in your industry/role
  
  
• Reflects your workload
  
  
• Backed by market data (yes, the IRS checks)
  
  

Pay too little = red flag.
 Pay too much = no tax savings.

We help you set this up with compliant W-2 payroll that’s IRS-proof, accurate, and part of your overall tax preparation services.

Don’t Forget: Forms, Filings & FBAR

Once you elect S Corp status, your tax world changes.

You Must:

• File Form 1120-S
  
  
• Issue yourself a W-2
  
  
• Issue 1099 NEC forms to contractors
  
  
• Collect W9 tax forms from every freelancer you work with
  
  
• Report foreign bank accounts over $10K with FBAR filing (FinCEN Form 114)
  
  
• Track 1099K income if you use platforms like PayPal or Stripe
  
  

This is why so many of our clients come to us after searching “CPA office near me” or “tax help near me.” Because you’re not just running a business, you’re now running a tax-compliant corporation.

What If You’re Not Ready for an S Corp?

That’s okay. There’s more than one way to reduce your tax burden without switching to an S Corp too early.

Smart Alternatives:

• Stick with your LLC, and use a Solo 401(k) or SEP IRA to lower taxable income.
  
  
• Build a plan to hit $50K+ in net profit so that switching later will deliver maximum ROI.
  
  
• Talk to a certified general accountant or taxation accountant about multi-entity strategy or deferred tax planning.
  
  

We’re not here to rush your decision. We’re here to get it right, for the long run.

What You Get with Insogna CPA

Whether you’re operating as an LLC, already an S Corp, or unsure what any of this means, we can help.

Our Services Include:

• Entity strategy sessions (LLC vs. S Corp vs. C Corp)
  
  
• Form 2553 filing and IRS correspondence
  
  
• Reasonable salary benchmarking and W-2 setup
  
  
• Full-service tax preparation services near you
  
  
• Payroll implementation and ongoing compliance
  
  
• FBAR filing, W9 collection, and 1099 NEC issuance
  
  
• Strategic tax planning from a certified public accountant near you
  
  

We’re not just one of many Austin CPA firms. We’re a team of detail-obsessed, entrepreneur-loving tax experts who speak your language.

Final Thoughts: It’s Not Just About Tax Savings, It’s About Strategy

An S Corp isn’t a cheat code, it’s a strategic move that works best when your business is ready. If you jump in too soon, it can become an expensive, paperwork-filled mess.

If you’re scaling, earning $50K+ in net profit, and ready to level up with CPA-certified support, we’ll help you transition the right way.

And if you’re not quite there yet? No problem. We’ll help you build toward it with tax savings every step of the way.

Book Your LLC vs. S Corp Consultation Today

Stop wondering. Stop guessing.

Schedule a consultation with Insogna CPA, your go-to CPA in Austin, Texas, and let’s make sure your business structure is designed to maximize your profits not your tax bill.

Because the only thing better than growing your business… is keeping more of what you earn while doing it.

..