Tax on Rental Income

Summary of What This Blog Covers

• Depreciation reduces taxable income over time.
  
  
• Rental expenses like utilities and repairs are deductible.
  
  
• Property taxes can be deducted beyond the SALT cap.
  
  
• Schedule E keeps rental income and deductions organized.

Some homes carry more than walls and windows.

They carry stories.
 Memories.
 Maybe even dreams you haven’t said out loud yet.

That second home, whether it’s a lakeside escape, a family legacy, or a quiet place for your parents to age with grace, wasn’t just a financial decision. It was an emotional one. And now, it’s asking something new of you.

Maybe it’s been sitting empty more than you’d like. Maybe you’ve thought about renting it out. Maybe you’re simply wondering if this beloved property could begin to work for you as much as you’ve worked for it.

And then, the questions begin to form.

“Would I even qualify for any tax benefits?”
 “Is it worth the effort to convert it into a rental?”
 “How do I do it the right way, without putting myself at risk later?”

You’re not alone. These questions are natural and the answers, while nuanced, are absolutely within reach.

Let’s walk through the five most valuable tax benefits of converting your second home into a rental property. We’ll explore not just the technical reasons, but the emotional clarity and long-term vision behind each.

But First, Why Structure Really Matters

Here’s something many well-intentioned homeowners miss: renting out a property whether for a few weeks a year or on a long-term lease doesn’t automatically make it a “rental” in the eyes of the IRS.

And here’s why that matters. You only receive full access to the tax benefits we’re about to explore if you structure your second home as a rental property correctly from the beginning.

To do that, you’ll need to:

• Draft a formal lease agreement
  
  
• Charge fair market rent and collect it consistently
  
  
• Track payments and rental-related expenses
  
  
• Keep your own personal use limited and documented
  
  
• File the appropriate forms, especially Schedule E
  
  
• Consider how it fits into your overall tax strategy with a professional
  
  

Without this structure, the IRS will consider your second home a personal-use property. That means no deductions for maintenance or depreciation, and no flexibility to apply net losses against your income.

Let’s imagine for a moment what it might feel like to get this right. To approach this decision with clarity instead of confusion. With confidence instead of guesswork. That’s what we’re building toward together.

1. Depreciation Write-Offs Reduce Your Taxable Income Over Time

Let’s start with what most people never hear from their tax preparer: depreciation is a gift that keeps on giving, if you’re eligible.

When you convert your second home into a qualified rental property, you’re allowed to deduct a portion of the home’s value each year as it “wears down” over time. This is called depreciation, and it’s a standard tax deduction available to rental property owners.

Here’s why it matters.

Unlike cash expenses, depreciation is a non-cash deduction. You’re not paying anything out of pocket. Instead, it’s a recognition that your property is losing value due to age and usage even if it’s actually appreciating on the market.

Most residential properties are depreciated over 27.5 years. That means if your property (excluding the land) is worth $275,000, you can deduct $10,000 each year from your rental income reported on Schedule E.

This deduction reduces your taxable income without reducing your real income, and it often pushes rental properties into a net loss on paper, which leads us to another benefit we’ll discuss shortly.

But depreciation isn’t available unless your property is structured correctly and that’s where having a certified public accountant near you who specializes in real estate becomes essential.

2. Utilities, Insurance, and Maintenance Become Deductible Business Expenses

Have you ever looked at your second home’s monthly costs and wondered why it feels like a full-time job without any tax relief?

Good news. When you make the switch to a qualified rental, those costs become tax-deductible business expenses.

This includes:

• Utilities like electricity, water, and internet
  
  
• Property insurance premiums
  
  
• HOA or condo association dues
  
  
• Landscaping, pest control, and minor repairs
  
  
• Advertising costs to find renters
  
  
• Legal or professional fees
  
  
• Payments to your tax preparer or CPA near you
  
  

These expenses reduce the net income of your rental on Schedule E, allowing you to report the property accurately and possibly reduce your total tax bill significantly.

The key here is documentation. Too often, homeowners miss deductions simply because they didn’t track expenses or weren’t sure what applied. That’s where our team at Insogna comes in. We offer not only tax planning, but modern accounting tools that make expense tracking easy and intuitive whether you’re managing the property yourself or using a property manager.

3. You Can Avoid the $10,000 SALT Cap on Property Tax Deductions

One of the more surprising tax benefits of converting your second home into a rental property is the ability to sidestep the State and Local Tax (SALT) deduction cap.

Here’s how it works.

As of current tax law, individuals can only deduct up to $10,000 in combined state income and property taxes on their personal tax return. This cap hits hard if you own multiple properties or live in a high-tax area.

However, when your second home qualifies as a rental, property taxes paid on that home are no longer subject to the SALT cap. Instead, they are treated as a business expense deducted in full on Schedule E.

This change alone can save property owners thousands of dollars per year, especially when paired with depreciation and other deductions.

And yet, this is one of the most underutilized strategies we see. It’s a perfect example of why having a CPA in Austin, Texas who proactively plans with you not just files your return is critical.

4. Schedule E Keeps Your Rental Income and Deductions Cleanly Organized

Many homeowners delay converting a second home to a rental because they’re worried it will complicate their taxes. The truth is, it can actually create more structure and clarity if done with intention.

Rental property income and expenses are reported on Schedule E, a dedicated section of your federal tax return designed specifically for this purpose. Schedule E allows you to:

• Itemize all expenses tied to the rental
  
  
• Include depreciation, insurance, utilities, and repairs
  
  
• Track net income (or losses) year over year
  
  
• Separate business use from personal use clearly
  
  
• Maintain audit-ready records, especially when supported by a certified tax accountant near you
  
  

Filing Schedule E also protects you from the common mistake of overreporting personal deductions or co-mingling expenses, something that becomes a major issue during an IRS review.

At Insogna, our clients don’t just receive a completed tax form. We build out the infrastructure from cloud-based software to financial reporting templates that makes Schedule E filing smooth, compliant, and empowering.

5. Net Operating Losses May Offset Other Income

This is one of the most strategic (and most overlooked) tax benefits of rental property ownership.

Let’s say your rental property shows a net loss on paper due to depreciation and deductible expenses. That loss may be used to offset other income like W-2 wages, self-employment earnings, or investment income if your adjusted gross income falls within certain thresholds.

Even if your income is too high to deduct the full loss immediately, unused passive losses may be carried forward to future years. In time, they can be applied against capital gains, other rental income, or even future profits from the property.

This kind of tax strategy isn’t obvious to most homeowners but it can make a major difference over the course of your financial life.

With guidance from a tax consultant in Austin or a licensed enrolled agent, you can turn what looks like a passive asset into a proactive tool for reducing your taxable income.

What This Means for You And Why It’s Bigger Than Just Taxes

This decision isn’t just about numbers.

It’s about being intentional. It’s about making a meaningful home into a sustainable part of your financial future. It’s about aligning your values with your structure so you can keep giving generously, while still receiving the peace of mind and tax advantages you’ve earned.

For some, the idea of becoming a “landlord” feels too commercial. That’s understandable. But reframing this move as an act of stewardship (caring for your home, your finances, and your legacy) can shift the perspective from overwhelm to empowerment.

At Insogna, we work with people who value integrity and clarity. People who want to do the right thing and are looking for the tools to do it confidently. We don’t just prepare taxes, we partner with you in planning them, aligning your numbers with your purpose.

A Personalized Roadmap Awaits

If this blog opened your eyes to the possibilities or confirmed that you’ve been managing your second home without a full picture of what’s possible, you’re not behind. You’re just ready for your next chapter.

We’d be honored to guide you.

Reach out to Insogna today and request your personalized rental-qualification checklist. We’ll assess your situation, clarify your options, and walk you through what it looks like to convert your second home into a clean, compliant, income-producing rental.

From structured lease support to Schedule E reporting, from depreciation planning to long-term wealth strategy, we’re here to make it make sense.

Because your second home deserves more than guesswork.
 It deserves a plan that honors the heart you put into it.

..

Summary of What This Blog Covers

• A second home needs a formal lease to qualify as a rental.
  
  
• You must charge fair market rent and document payments.
  
  
• Personal use must be limited and tracked.
  
  
• Clear records allow legal tax deductions and audit protection.

A Question That Keeps Many Up at Night

You bought a second home. Maybe it was a quiet retreat tucked in the hills of Texas. Maybe it’s a home your children will inherit one day. Maybe it was for your parents, or your siblings, or to honor the memory of someone you love.

It might have been paid in full. Or maybe you took out a small mortgage, but your goal was simple: create a safe space, a long-term investment, a place that meant something. Not a business. Not a rental empire. Just something steady. Something personal.

And yet, here you are. You’re asking questions you didn’t anticipate:

• “Can I write off any of the expenses?”
  
  
• “Is it considered a rental even if I don’t charge rent?”
  
  
• “What does the IRS even mean by ‘personal use’ versus ‘rental use’?”
  
  

It can feel like the rules are built for someone else. Someone less generous. Someone more transactional. You’re not trying to exploit the system, you just want to do the right thing and not get blindsided in the process.

You’re not alone.

Why So Many Get This Wrong And Why It Matters Now More Than Ever

At Insogna, we’ve seen this situation unfold more times than we can count. A family buys a second home for a loved one. Or they rent it out occasionally. Or they just leave it empty, with plans for later. Either way, they walk into tax season with assumptions and those assumptions often clash with how the IRS sees things.

Why? Because the IRS doesn’t look at your second home through the lens of generosity or intent. It looks at structure, documentation, and financial behavior.

And without the right structure, your second home could be classified in a way that not only denies you potential tax deductions, but may even trigger penalties if deductions are claimed incorrectly.

This isn’t about trying to “game” the system. This is about understanding it deeply enough to honor your values while protecting your finances.

The IRS View: Personal Use vs. Rental Use Defined

To the IRS, a property must follow clear, consistent rules in order to qualify as a rental for tax purposes. That means:

• A formal lease agreement is in place.
  
  
• The tenant pays fair market rent
  
  
• You keep records of all payments and expenses.
  
  
• Your own personal use of the property is minimal and tracked.
  
  

If these elements aren’t in place, the IRS defaults to treating your second home as personal-use property. That means most of the deductions that would normally be available to a rental property like depreciation, maintenance, and utilities are no longer available.

And here’s the real twist: if you do deduct those expenses but don’t meet the IRS requirements, you may be required to pay them back later, often with interest and penalties.

The message is clear. If you want your second home to be considered a rental property in the eyes of the IRS, you have to act like a landlord even when you’re renting to someone you love.

A Real Story: Love, Legacy, and a Missed Opportunity

Let me share a story. Not to scare you but to show you how easy this mistake is to make.

A client we’ll call Laura bought a small cottage in Dripping Springs. She had no plans to rent it out on Airbnb. No dreams of becoming a real estate mogul. She just wanted her sister, who was going through a divorce, to have a place to stay while she got back on her feet.

Laura paid the taxes. She maintained the property. She even paid for internet and lawn care. So when tax time came, she assumed she could deduct at least some of those costs. After all, the home was being used and she was the one footing the bill.

But there was no lease. No rent. No written agreement. Just a quiet understanding between siblings.

The IRS saw that as personal use. And when Laura submitted her taxes, listing deductions for repairs and depreciation, the red flags were raised. A year later, she received a letter. Then a fine. Then the realization that her generous act had become a financial mess.

Laura didn’t do anything unethical. She didn’t cut corners or try to cheat the system. She simply didn’t know.

That’s why we’re here to help you know.

The Good News: Structure Creates Safety

Let’s walk through what the IRS actually wants to see. If you want your second home to qualify for rental tax treatment, here’s what you need:

1. A Formal Lease Agreement

Even if your tenant is a family member, you need a lease in writing. This should include:

• The full names of landlord and tenant
  
  
• The monthly rent amount
  
  
• Start and end dates
  
  
• Payment due dates
  
  
• Any included utilities or services
  
  
• Responsibilities for maintenance and repairs
  
  

This isn’t just paperwork. It’s evidence of intent. It shows the IRS that you’re treating the arrangement as a business transaction, not as a favor.

Your certified public accountant or a trusted legal resource can help you draft a lease that meets local and federal requirements.

2. Charging Market-Rate Rent

This is where many people trip up. They want to help someone, so they offer the home at a steep discount or no rent at all.

That’s a beautiful thing, but it doesn’t qualify for rental treatment.

To meet IRS standards, you must charge what the market would support. If homes in your area rent for $1,500/month, and you’re charging $200, that will likely be reclassified as personal use.

You can find market rents by:

• Checking local rental listings
  
  
• Using online tools like Rentometer or Zillow
  
  
• Asking a property manager for an estimate
  
  

Be sure to document your research, so you can back up your rental rate if ever questioned.

3. Consistent, Documented Payments

Once you set the rent, it must actually be paid and paid in a traceable, consistent manner.

• Avoid cash.
  
  
• Use checks, bank transfers, or online payment platforms.
  
  
• Keep records of every payment, and track any late or missed ones.
  
  

The goal isn’t just to collect money. It’s to show that the home is being operated like a real rental.

If rent isn’t paid, or is inconsistent, the IRS may challenge the entire arrangement.

4. Track Your Personal Use

You’re allowed to use your second home personally but only to a point.

Here’s the rule: you can use the home for up to 14 days per year OR 10% of the total days it’s rented at fair market value whichever is greater.

If you use it more than that, it becomes a personal residence in the eyes of the IRS, and your deductions become limited or disallowed.

That means vacations, holidays, or quick weekend getaways all count. Even if the home is empty, personal use still counts against the limit.

Keep a calendar or log of all usage: who was there, when, and for how long. It may feel tedious, but it’s a small act of protection for your peace of mind.

5. Track and Categorize All Expenses

Once your second home is structured properly, you can begin claiming appropriate deductions:

• Property taxes
  
  
• Mortgage interest
  
  
• Insurance premiums
  
  
• Utilities (if you pay them)
  
  
• Repairs and maintenance
  
  
• Professional fees (property manager, accountant)
  
  
• Depreciation over time
  
  

Having a clear record of income and expenses doesn’t just help at tax time, it helps you understand how your asset is performing over time.

And if you ever face an audit? You’ll have the receipts, literally.

Why This Matters: The Bigger Picture

At Insogna, we don’t just prepare taxes. We partner with people who want to make confident decisions, who care deeply about doing things right, and who often carry more emotional weight into their finances than they realize.

We understand that second homes are emotional. They’re about family, memory, future planning. They’re not just line items. They’re love letters.

That’s why we bring both precision and compassion to the conversation.

When you structure your second home with intention, you aren’t giving up your values. You’re protecting them. You’re creating a safe space for generosity and legacy to coexist with clarity and compliance.

Questions You Might Still Be Wondering

Can I switch how the home is used later?

Yes. A second home can transition between personal and rental use. But it must be tracked carefully. A property rented part of the year and used personally another part must allocate deductions proportionally.

What if I missed this in past years?

You’re not alone. It’s common. We can help you amend past returns if needed and create a strategy going forward. What matters is starting now.

What if the home is abroad?

Then FBAR filing requirements may apply. We’ll help you determine if your foreign property is subject to reporting and structure it properly to avoid steep penalties.

Ready to Make Your Second Home Work for You?

If this blog raised more questions than answers or if you now realize you might be in a gray area, you’re not alone. This topic is one of the most emotionally layered and technically misunderstood areas of tax planning.

That’s why we invite you to schedule a one-on-one session with a licensed CPA at Insogna.

We’ll review your current situation, answer your questions, and build a plan to move forward with confidence. Whether you’re already renting, just beginning, or completely unsure, we’re here, not to judge, but to guide.

Book Your Personalized Rental Strategy Consultation

Let’s turn uncertainty into clarity. Let’s protect the home you love, the people you care for, and the financial future you’re building.

You’ve done the hard work of showing up for others. Now let us show up for you.

Reach out to Insogna today. Your second home deserves more than guesswork. It deserves a structure that supports your values and your peace of mind.

..

Summary of What This Blog Covers

• Why CPAs help correctly classify rental expenses for tax savings.
  
  
• How passive losses carry forward and reduce future taxes.
  
  
• Tips on claiming shared expenses like utilities and home office use.
  
  
• The importance of audit prep and long-term tax planning.

There is something deeply empowering about buying your first rental property. Whether you inherited the real estate bug from your parents or stumbled into real estate as a thoughtful way to diversify your portfolio, that moment: signing the closing documents, picking up the keys carries a certain weight. For many, it marks the beginning of a new chapter. One that whispers, You’re building something of your own now.

It’s not just about income. It’s about security. Autonomy. Long-term possibility. But as quickly as the pride sets in, so does something else: the question of what happens next.

You’ve already found tenants or you’re preparing your first listing. You’re managing repairs, watching your bank statements, and maybe already thinking about how to track income and expenses. Somewhere in there, a new, quieter question surfaces:

Am I handling the tax side of this correctly?

If you’ve asked that, even once, this blog is for you.

Because here’s the truth: the transition from homeowner to landlord carries with it a shift in responsibility. And one of the most important, yet easily overlooked, responsibilities is understanding the tax implications of owning a rental property.

But you’re not expected to know it all. You’re not supposed to figure it out alone. That’s where a CPA comes in. Not just as a tax preparer, but as a strategic partner in building the future you’re working so hard for.

Let’s walk through five key reasons why a CPA is not a “nice-to-have” for your first rental, it’s an essential part of your foundation.

1. Depreciation vs. Expensing Improvements: What’s the Difference, and Why Does It Matter?

When you purchase a rental property, you inevitably spend money to get it ready. Maybe it’s cosmetic: paint, floors, new appliances. Maybe it’s more substantial: plumbing, a new roof, a major HVAC overhaul.

You know you’ve spent money. It feels reasonable to assume you can deduct it.

But this is where rental property taxes become tricky.

The IRS makes a firm distinction between repairs, which are deductible in the year they’re paid, and capital improvements, which must be depreciated over 27.5 years. That’s a long time.

If you’re not working with someone who understands these categories intimately, you might deduct something you shouldn’t or worse, miss the chance to deduct something you could have.

A CPA in Austin, Texas, or wherever you’re based, will walk through your expense history line by line, asking the kinds of clarifying questions that software never can. They’ll explain that while replacing a few broken tiles may be a repair, re-tiling an entire kitchen floor is a capital improvement. One affects your taxes now. The other affects them for decades.

And this distinction matters, not only for this year’s return but for the long arc of your property’s financial journey.

2. Passive Loss Rules and the Importance of Carryforward Strategy

Here’s a scenario we see often: You own a property. You’ve carefully tracked your expenses. Your Schedule E shows a loss. You expect that loss to reduce your taxable income. But then your CPA tells you that the loss won’t be applied this year. Your income is too high.

You’re confused. Maybe even a little defeated.

This is what’s known as the passive activity loss limitation. And it affects many high-earning new landlords. When your adjusted gross income (AGI) exceeds $150,000, the IRS limits your ability to deduct passive losses against your other income.

But here’s the piece that gets overlooked: those losses are not lost. They are suspended, carried forward year after year, quietly accumulating until they can be used. They can be applied against future passive income or when you sell the property.

We meet so many clients who weren’t told this. Who didn’t know to track their suspended losses. Who sold a property and missed out on a major opportunity to reduce capital gains because those losses were never recorded properly.

A certified CPA near you will ensure that every dollar you’ve spent: every loss, every expense, is carried forward appropriately. They’re not just preparing your return. They’re protecting your future benefit.

Because what doesn’t show up on this year’s tax return might become your greatest tax shield five years from now.

3. Gray Area Deductions: Utilities, Shared Spaces, and Home Office Use

Not all rental properties come with clean, separate utility bills and neatly divided expenses. Many new landlords are renting out a unit in a duplex, a backyard ADU, or even part of their primary residence. Suddenly, your electricity, water, and internet bills are shared. The lines blur.

You might be wondering:

• How much of the internet bill can I deduct?
  
  
• What if I pay for garbage collection for the whole building?
  
  
• Can I deduct my home office if I manage everything from my dining room table?
  
  

These aren’t just technical questions. They’re questions about compliance and confidence.

A taxation accountant or chartered professional accountant will help you answer these questions with care and integrity. They’ll ask you to walk them through your property, your systems, your workflow. Not to test you, but to understand you. To ensure that your deductions are grounded in logic, supported by documentation, and compliant with IRS expectations.

This is one of the most human aspects of tax strategy. It requires relationship. Conversation. Nuance. And the right CPA will offer exactly that.

4. Audit Readiness: Not Just for the Paranoid, But for the Prepared

Let’s pause here for a moment.

We’re not suggesting you should expect to be audited. Most landlords won’t be. But the question is not will you be audited? The question is if you are, how will you feel?

Will you feel anxious? Embarrassed? Scrambling to find receipts in shoeboxes?

Or will you feel composed? Confident? Ready?

A CPA office near you will help you build that readiness into your year not just into your April. They’ll teach you how to store records, how to label documents, how to categorize transactions correctly the first time.

And in doing so, they’re giving you something more valuable than a deduction. They’re giving you a sense of control.

That matters. Especially when you’re new to this.

5. Future Planning: Exit Strategy, Depreciation Recapture, and 1031 Exchanges

This is the part most new landlords don’t think about but it may be the most important.

Someday, you’ll sell your property. Maybe you’ll upgrade, maybe you’ll cash out. When that time comes, your tax impact will depend on the records and planning you do now.

Will you have clear records of capital improvements to increase your property’s basis and reduce capital gains?

Will you be prepared for depreciation recapture and its tax implications?

Will you be in a position to roll your gains into a 1031 exchange and defer your taxes entirely?

A small business CPA in Austin can walk you through these decisions before they’re urgent. They’ll help you see what’s around the corner, not just what’s in front of you.

Because a good tax strategy is not reactive. It’s intentional. It’s quiet foresight that pays off in the moments when it matters most.

The Deeper Why: Because This Is About More Than Just Numbers

Let’s return to where we began.

You didn’t invest in real estate for the sake of deductions. You did it to build something. Maybe for your children. Maybe to retire earlier. Maybe to prove to yourself that you could.

That goal? It deserves clarity. It deserves strategy. It deserves a partner who understands not only how the tax system works but how you work.

At Insogna, we’ve sat across the table from first-time landlords who were proud, excited, and more than a little overwhelmed. We’ve walked with them from that first purchase through their first filing, their first refinance, their first sale.

And what we’ve learned is that taxes are never just taxes. They are the financial expression of your story. And your story deserves to be told well.

Final Thoughts: Let’s Build Something You Can Be Proud Of

If you’ve just purchased your first rental property, you’re standing at the start of something. It’s okay to feel unsure. It’s okay to ask questions. What matters most is that you build a team that supports your vision.

Working with a CPA isn’t about spreadsheets. It’s about building a system of care around your investment. One that sees where you’re headed and helps you get there with integrity, insight, and support.

At Insogna, that’s what we do. We’re more than accountants. We’re guides. We’re educators. We’re partners in your path forward.

If you’re ready to move from confusion to clarity, from stress to strategy, reach out. We’d be honored to walk this part of the journey with you.

..

Summary of What This Blog Covers

• High earners may not deduct rental losses now due to IRS limits.
  
  
• Losses aren’t lost. They carry forward for future tax benefits.
  
  
• Tracking expenses and depreciation is essential.
  
  
• Strategic planning with a real estate-savvy CPA unlocks long-term savings.

You’ve worked hard to reach this level. You’re earning well, building stability, perhaps even fulfilling a long-held dream of financial independence. You might be a physician working demanding hours, a business owner juggling growth and overhead, or a tech professional managing teams and investments. Wherever you’re coming from, one thing is clear: you didn’t land in this position by accident. You’ve made smart, thoughtful decisions. And one of those was adding real estate to your financial plan.

It makes sense, right? Real estate is tangible. It’s a hedge. It can offer passive income, appreciation, tax advantages. You’ve read the books, heard the podcasts, maybe even sat through a seminar or two. You know that real estate is supposed to help build wealth not just in the short term, but over a lifetime.

So you purchase a rental property. You track expenses, pay for repairs, maybe even get a property manager. Your Schedule E shows a loss. You’re thinking, “Great, this will offset my income and reduce my taxes.”

But then your CPA says something you didn’t expect.

They tell you that your rental loss won’t reduce your taxes. At least not this year. Why? Because your income is too high.

You’re confused. Maybe even frustrated.

This is where we begin.

The Emotion Behind the Numbers

Let’s not rush past the feeling part of this. If you’re someone who’s trying to do the right thing (saving diligently, investing thoughtfully, building a future with intention), being told that your smart move won’t help you this year is deflating. It feels unfair. And maybe a little demoralizing.

You might ask: If I’m paying for repairs, property taxes, insurance, interest, and I’m even depreciating the building, why don’t I see those losses reflected on my tax return?

You are not alone in this question. And more importantly, you’re not wrong for asking it.

What you’re encountering is a little-known, often misunderstood area of the tax code called passive activity loss limitations. And while it might not help you this year, it holds immense value for your future if you understand how to use it.

Why the Rules Exist (And Why They Affect You)

To appreciate what’s happening, it helps to understand why these limitations exist.

The IRS wants to prevent high-income earners from using passive losses to completely eliminate taxes on their non-passive income. So they created thresholds. Once your adjusted gross income (AGI) rises above $150,000, your ability to deduct rental real estate losses begins to disappear.

Technically:

• If your AGI is under $100,000 and you “actively participate” in your rental (which most landlords do), you can deduct up to $25,000 in passive losses.
  
  
• Between $100,000 and $150,000, that deduction phases out.
  
  
• Once your AGI exceeds $150,000, the deduction disappears entirely.
  
  

So if you’re earning six figures or more, it’s likely that any rental losses you show this year will be suspended.

But here’s where the story takes a turn.

Because these losses aren’t lost. They’re carried forward. Quietly. Year after year.

They accumulate in your tax file, becoming an invisible reserve of future tax savings like credits stored away in your name, waiting for their moment.

The Why That Matters More Than the “When”

At Insogna, we believe that understanding why we track passive losses even when they don’t affect your tax bill in the moment is foundational to building long-term wealth.

There’s a difference between compliance and strategy.

Compliance checks boxes. Strategy builds futures.

And when we talk about passive rental losses, we’re not just talking about depreciation schedules and AGI thresholds. We’re talking about building systems that allow your investments to serve you, not just now, but when you need them most: during transitions, sales, years of lower income, or future reinvestment.

So the deeper purpose here isn’t to find immediate deductions. It’s to steward your investments with the clarity and care they deserve.

Let’s Translate This Into Real Life

Imagine you own a rental property. You’ve had to repaint, fix a plumbing leak, pay property taxes, and replace the water heater. You’ve also paid interest on the mortgage and depreciated the structure itself.

On paper, this property has a net loss of $8,000.

If you’re earning $175,000 in AGI, you won’t be able to deduct that $8,000 this year. But it won’t be forgotten.

It gets added to a passive loss carryforward account, an IRS-recognized figure that follows you year to year.

Now imagine three years from now, you decide to sell that property. You’ve accumulated $24,000 in suspended losses. When you sell, those losses will offset your capital gains from the sale.

If you sell and realize a $60,000 gain, that $24,000 will reduce it to $36,000 in taxable profit. That’s a significant tax saving, especially if you’re in a high-income tax bracket.

A Common Misconception: “If I Can’t Use It Now, Why Track It?”

Because the IRS will use your numbers. Whether you do or not.

What we’ve seen, unfortunately, is high earners who don’t document everything because they believe it won’t matter until “someday.” Then, someday comes. They sell a property. And no one knows what their carryforward losses are. They left money behind, simply because the records weren’t there.

Passive losses are real, even when they’re deferred.

They require:

• Accurate tracking of every expense
  
  
• Clear documentation of capital improvements (vs. repairs)
  
  
• Meticulous depreciation schedules
  
  
• Consistency from year to year
  
  

If you’re not sure whether your CPA is doing this? It’s okay to ask.

In fact, it’s necessary.

The Emotional Cost of Missed Deductions

We’ve had conversations with clients who sold a property, celebrated the gain, and then discovered a year later that they paid far more in taxes than they should have because their suspended losses weren’t tracked, applied, or even recorded.

That’s not just a missed deduction. That’s a missed opportunity.

It’s also a loss of trust in a system that already feels complex.

We’re here to restore that trust.

What You Can Do Starting Today

Even if you feel like it’s too late, it’s not. You can begin now. And here’s how.

1. Document every rental expense.

Yes, even if you’re not deducting them this year. This includes:

• Mortgage interest
  
  
• Insurance
  
  
• Property taxes
  
  
• Repairs and maintenance
  
  
• Depreciation (calculated annually)
  
  
• Professional fees (your tax consultant near you, for example)
  
  
• Utilities and management fees
  
  

A good CPA will help you categorize these correctly. A great CPA will make sure they’re recorded and stored consistently so nothing gets lost.

2. Maintain a capital improvements log.

Replacing a roof, remodeling a kitchen, or adding square footage? These aren’t annual expenses. They’re capitalized and depreciated over time. When it’s time to sell, this history will directly affect how much you owe or don’t owe.

3. Get clear on your passive loss carryforward.

Ask your CPA for the number. It should appear on your Schedule E each year. Know it. Track it. Understand how it fits into your bigger picture.

4. Plan for timing.

Some clients have one lower-income year: a sabbatical, a maternity leave, a business pivot. That year may allow you to unlock suspended losses.

Others use suspended losses to offset capital gains in sale years or through careful sequencing of 1031 exchanges.

When Strategy Replaces Surprise

You’ve likely experienced tax season as a time of reaction. You get the documents. You send them in. You wait for the result.

But there’s another way.

What if you viewed your tax plan as a financial tool, not a compliance task?
 What if tax planning wasn’t something you dread but something that brings clarity?

That’s the shift we make with our clients.

Because wealth, in our view, isn’t just about how much you make. It’s about how well you steward it. How intentionally you grow it. And how supported you feel in the process.

The Collective Goal

Let’s pause for a moment to remember why this matters.

It’s not about the tax code. It’s not about line items. It’s not even about the refund.

It’s about building financial lives that align with our goals. It’s about leveraging the systems that exist, imperfect though they may be, to serve our future.

When we understand our rental losses, when we track what’s invisible, and when we partner with the right support to turn confusion into clarity, we build more than deductions. We build momentum.

Final Thoughts: There’s More Waiting for You

If you’ve been earning six figures, investing in real estate, and walking away from tax season feeling disappointed or confused, you’re not alone.

But you don’t have to stay in that place.

Passive rental losses may be quiet for now. But they are building. They are cumulative. And with the right planning, they will become part of your wealth engine.

At Insogna, we help clients track, plan, and use those losses as tools for future growth. We don’t just want you to “file taxes.” We want you to understand how the tax code can work in your favor not because you’re gaming the system, but because you’re using it wisely.

If you’re looking for a CPA in Austin, Texas, or a licensed CPA near you who sees the full picture of your goals, your numbers, and your heart, we’re here for you.

Let’s make the invisible work for you. Let’s build something you’re proud of.

..

Summary of What This Blog Covers

• Traditional donor-advised funds (DAFs) limit control and flexibility.
  
  
• iCLATs offer tax-efficient giving with long-term benefits.
  
  
• Strategic planning aligns giving with business and estate goals.
  
  
• Insogna helps you give smarter with tailored structures.

You’ve probably heard it before: “Just give to a donor-advised fund. It’s easy.”

And sure, at first glance, it seems like a clean solution especially if you’re in the middle of a liquidity event, your business just sold, or your income has soared in a high-growth year.

You care deeply about making a difference. You’re generous. You’re intentional.

But somewhere between signing DAF paperwork and seeing your tax return, a question bubbles up:
 “Is this really the best way to give?”

You’re not second-guessing your generosity. You’re rethinking the structure. And honestly? That’s smart.

Because when your giving goals grow bigger and your financial world becomes more complex, you need strategies that can grow with you.

Let’s walk through what’s going wrong, why traditional giving vehicles may be too rigid for your vision, and what smarter, more empowering alternatives exist for people like you. People who want to give boldly and wisely.

The Problem: Generosity Without Strategy Can Create Tax Headaches

You’re doing what most people dream of: making a meaningful impact with your wealth. But here’s what you might not know: if your giving isn’t structured correctly, it can cause tax friction rather than relief.

Yes, even with a donor-advised fund (DAF).

Here’s what happens in the background when you put assets into a DAF:

• You’ve made an irrevocable gift. Those funds are no longer yours, not even a little bit.
  
  
• You might receive an immediate tax deduction, but if you mistime that deduction or over-donate in a low-income year, you may lose valuable tax benefits.
  
  
• The DAF sponsor, typically a large financial institution, has control over investments, not you.
  
  
• And perhaps worst of all, your giving strategy becomes static, disconnected from your life’s changes or future planning needs.
  
  

So while your intention is beautiful, your tax position may not be. And we believe your giving should feel both good-hearted and good for your financial future.

Why This Happens: DAFs Weren’t Designed for Complex Lives

Donor-advised funds were created to simplify giving. And in many ways, they do. They’re helpful for:

• Annual donations with modest assets
  
  
• People who need a quick deduction before year-end
  
  
• Giving without the responsibility of managing a private foundation
  
  

But if you’re running multiple businesses, selling appreciated assets, managing trusts, or building intergenerational wealth, you’ve outgrown a one-size-fits-all model.

What you need is a structure that:

• Aligns with your tax goals
  
  
• Adjusts to market conditions
  
  
• Keeps your capital working while giving
  
  
• Offers you choices over time, not just up front
  
  

Enter smarter vehicles like Charitable Lead Annuity Trusts (iCLATs), enhanced donor accounts, and integrated estate strategies.

Let’s Compare: DAF vs. iCLAT, What’s the Difference?

Let’s go deeper into how these can work in real life.

Option 1: The iCLAT: Powerful, Predictable, and Purposeful

You know we love a good metaphor, so think of an iCLAT like this:
 It’s a long-haul train delivering gifts to charity on a scheduled track while also circling back to return wealth to your family or estate.

Here’s how it actually works:

1. You transfer appreciated assets or cash into a trust.
   
   
2. The trust sends annual payments (a fixed annuity) to qualified charities for a specific number of years.
   
   
3. After that term ends, typically 5 to 20 years, any remaining trust assets return to you or your named beneficiaries.
   
   

Why it’s such a powerful tool:

• You get a significant up-front income tax deduction often more than with a DAF.
  
  
• You can time the funding of the trust based on your tax needs, such as a high-income year from a business exit or asset sale.
  
  
• You keep investment control inside the trust, letting you grow the assets during the annuity term.
  
  
• You build charitable impact and multigenerational wealth, all in one move.
  
  

Option 2: Enhanced Donor-Advised Accounts with Strategic Support

We’re not saying DAFs are all bad. In fact, with the right provider and guidance from a certified public accountant (CPA) who gets it, they can be a solid piece of your giving strategy.

Some modern DAFs offer:

• Fully customizable investment portfolios
  
  
• ESG-aligned or values-based fund choices
  
  
• Fast, flexible grant-making
  
  
• Coordination with business giving or family foundations
  
  

But the real magic happens when your DAF isn’t just a static tool, but a piece of a larger plan aligned with your estate, your annual income, and your values.

This is where working with a firm like Insogna makes all the difference.

We build a customized charitable roadmap that includes:

• DAF + iCLAT integration, so you’re not locked into one strategy
  
  
• Market-timed giving, especially if you’re holding appreciated stock or crypto
  
  
• Entity coordination, for those managing LLCs, S-Corps, or trusts
  
  
• Legacy planning, so your giving aligns with your estate documents and family goals
  
  

Where It Gets Even Smarter: Strategic Giving for Business Owners

If you’re an entrepreneur or founder, your giving strategy must be deeply integrated with your business lifecycle.

Let’s say:

• You’re preparing to sell your company
  
  
• You’re planning to gift equity or interests to charity
  
  
• You’re balancing annual income, capital gains, and estate goals
  
  

With proactive CPA-led planning, we can help you:

• Transfer ownership before liquidity for maximum tax benefit
  
  
• Avoid triggering large capital gains by donating appreciated shares
  
  
• Align trust terms and charitable distributions with your post-sale lifestyle
  
  

This is next-level giving, and it requires a team that understands tax law, financial forecasting, and legacy planning.

Not just a “tax preparer near you.”
 Not just an “accountant firm.”
 A real, proactive, detail-obsessed partner.

That’s what we do.

And Don’t Forget About FBAR and International Considerations

Got foreign holdings? Offshore investments? International charities you support?

You’ll want to make sure your charitable strategy also aligns with:

• FBAR filing requirements
  
  
• FATCA compliance
  
  
• Foreign grant rules
  
  
• Treaty considerations for dual citizens
  
  

Miss a disclosure and you could face stiff penalties. Overlook international complexities, and your gift might be delayed or rejected.

We’ve helped clients gift through iCLATs and DAFs while ensuring full reporting and global alignment. It’s complex but it’s possible, and deeply rewarding.

Let’s Recap: Why Your Charitable Structure Matters

• It impacts your taxes. Poor timing or improper structure can cost you thousands.
  
  
• It affects your flexibility. A locked DAF means no going back.
  
  
• It shapes your legacy. Strategic structures return wealth to your family after impact.
  
  
• It reflects your values. Giving tools should align with your ethics, not just your taxes.
  
  

What You Deserve: A Giving Strategy As Thoughtful As You Are

Your generosity is not an afterthought. It’s central to who you are.

At Insogna, we believe your giving strategy should feel:

• Empowering
  
  
• Flexible
  
  
• Aligned with your whole financial picture
  
  
• Optimized to grow with you, not hold you back
  
  

We’re not just number crunchers. We’re story listeners. We’re strategy builders. We’re wealth and purpose professionals.

Whether you’re based in Austin or anywhere in the U.S., we work alongside business owners, families, and philanthropic leaders to design giving plans that match exactly where they are and where they’re going.

Ready to Give Smarter?

If you’ve ever wondered:

• “Is my giving creating risk?”
  
  
• “Could I be giving more efficiently?”
  
  
• “How do I keep flexibility as my wealth grows?”
  
  

It’s time to get some answers and better yet, a plan.

Let’s build a giving strategy that’s as big as your heart and as smart as your goals.

Schedule your complimentary charitable planning consultation with Insogna today.
 We’ll review your existing DAF, explore trust strategies like iCLATs, and help you align your generosity with your growth.

Because your purpose deserves precision. And your giving deserves a structure that truly works.

..