The 5 Biggest Tax Mistakes Business Owners Make (And How to Avoid Them)

1 5

Summary of What This Blog Covers:

  • Unpacking the most common tax pitfalls business owners face – This blog identifies the five most frequent tax mistakes entrepreneurs make, from rushing into S Corp elections to failing to track deductible expenses, and explains the financial impact of each misstep.

  • How a CPA offers year-round tax strategy, not just seasonal filing – It highlights the strategic advantage of working with a proactive CPA in Austin, Texas who goes beyond basic compliance to offer ongoing guidance, tax projections, entity structuring, and planning that maximizes savings.

  • The risks of ignoring IRS requirements and compliance responsibilities – The blog details the dangers of neglecting quarterly estimated payments, mixing business and personal finances, or missing important filings like 1099s and W9s, and how a CPA helps maintain full IRS compliance.

  • Why Insogna CPA is the trusted partner for growth-oriented business owners – It presents Insogna CPA as a flat-fee, cloud-based CPA firm offering dedicated, expert support to service-based businesses, self-employed professionals, and companies scaling with contractors and multiple income streams.

If you’re a business owner, you already know taxes aren’t just about writing a check in April. They impact every financial decision you make. From how you pay yourself, to what you invest in, to how quickly you can scale. Yet so many entrepreneurs don’t treat taxes like a strategic part of their business until it’s too late.

The result? Missed deductions, painful penalties, and lost profits.

At Insogna CPA, we’ve seen just about every tax mistake you can imagine. Some small, some expensive, all avoidable. That’s why we’re breaking down the five biggest tax mistakes business owners make and, more importantly, how you can avoid them by working with a proactive, strategic CPA in Austin, Texas.

Whether you’re managing 1099 contractors, filing W9 forms, or navigating your first S Corp election, these insights will help you keep more of what you earn and grow with confidence.

Mistake #1: Rushing Into an S Corp Election

Why It Happens:

S Corps are often touted as a tax-saving miracle for small business owners. You’ll hear, “You’ll save thousands on self-employment tax,” or “Your tax bill will drop overnight.” But what many don’t realize is that the S Corp election only works when your business is consistently profitable and ready to handle the administrative lift that comes with it.

What You Risk:

  • Increased costs for payroll compliance

  • Additional federal filings (like Form 1120S and K-1s)

  • IRS scrutiny over what counts as a “reasonable salary”

  • Potential overpayment if you’re not profitable enough

What a CPA Will Do:

A qualified small business CPA in Austin doesn’t just file paperwork. They run real calculations and build a financial model to compare your current tax liability versus an S Corp structure. They evaluate:

  • Whether your net income supports the S Corp model

  • How much you should pay yourself via W-2

  • The timing of the election and potential retroactive filings

At Insogna CPA, we analyze your last 12–18 months of financials and forecast the next 12 so we can time your S Corp election perfectly, ensuring it saves you money rather than increasing your tax burden.

Mistake #2: Mixing Personal and Business Expenses

Why It Happens:

Life moves fast. You grab your business card for lunch and forget it wasn’t a client meeting. Or you cover a vendor expense on your personal card and never transfer the transaction. It may feel harmless, but to the IRS, it’s a serious red flag.

What You Risk:

  • Loss of deduction eligibility

  • Weakened legal protection for your LLC or corporation

  • IRS audits and penalties

  • Difficulty producing clean, credible books for investors or lenders

What a CPA Will Do:

A tax accountant near you will not only help you clean up past records but also create systems to prevent commingling in the future. This includes:

  • Setting up dedicated business checking and credit accounts

  • Implementing QuickBooks Self-Employed or other tracking tools

  • Using integrated apps to scan and categorize receipts

  • Reconciling your accounts monthly to ensure all transactions are accurate

Our team trains clients and their teams on how to properly document business expenses and keeps financial records IRS-compliant at all times.

Mistake #3: Ignoring Quarterly Estimated Tax Payments

Why It Happens:

When you start making consistent income as a self-employed professional or 1099 contractor, it’s easy to forget that the IRS expects tax payments throughout the year, not just in April. Without an employer withholding taxes for you, the responsibility falls entirely on your shoulders.

What You Risk:

  • Penalties and interest for underpayment

  • A huge tax bill in April that you weren’t prepared for

  • Cash flow crises that derail growth plans

What a CPA Will Do:

A CPA firm in Austin, Texas doesn’t wait until tax season to get involved. We calculate your quarterly estimates and help you plan accordingly.

We use tools like the 1099 tax calculator and review your current income and deductions to determine how much to pay each quarter. We’ll also ensure you qualify for safe harbor rules to avoid underpayment penalties.

We guide our clients through:

  • When and how to make estimated payments (Federal and State)

  • Adjustments based on fluctuating income

  • Coordination with payroll if you’re an S Corp

Mistake #4: Not Tracking Deductible Expenses

Why It Happens:

You’re busy running your business. Small purchases like subscriptions, parking, or client gifts slip through the cracks. Maybe you’re tracking the big stuff (office rent, marketing), but if you’re not logging every expense, you’re giving the IRS a bigger check than they deserve.

What You Risk:

  • Lost deductions

  • Overstated profits (which increase your tax liability)

  • Missed opportunities for legitimate write-offs

What a CPA Will Do:

A strategic tax advisor in Austin will walk you through every category of deductible expenses and help you implement systems that make tracking automatic.

Common missed deductions include:

  • Business mileage

  • Cell phone and internet use

  • Continuing education and certifications

  • Subscriptions and digital tools

  • Professional service fees (yes, including your CPA)

We also train business owners on how to keep clean records, store receipts, and properly allocate shared expenses like rent or utilities.

Mistake #5: Only Engaging a CPA During Tax Season

Why It Happens:

You think you’re saving money by keeping things DIY until tax season rolls around. But what you’re actually doing is limiting your ability to make proactive financial moves throughout the year.

What You Risk:

  • Missed tax planning opportunities

  • No time to correct course before year-end

  • Limited visibility into tax-saving options like retirement planning or deferred revenue

What a CPA Will Do:

Engaging a CPA near you year-round means having a financial partner who’s always thinking a few steps ahead.

At Insogna CPA, we offer:

  • Quarterly strategy sessions

  • Tax projections based on current performance

  • Retirement and healthcare planning

  • Entity reviews and restructuring recommendations

  • Ongoing compliance checks to keep you out of trouble

With our licensed CPAs, enrolled agents, and dedicated support team, you’re not just reacting to taxes, you’re controlling them.

Bonus Mistake: Failing to File IRS Compliance Forms Like W9s and 1099s

Why It Happens:

You hire contractors, they do great work, you pay them… and forget to request their W9 form or send a 1099 NEC at year-end. It’s a common oversight but one that can result in fines.

What You Risk:

  • Penalties for late or missing 1099 filings

  • IRS audits for misclassified workers

  • Lack of documentation for deductible contractor expenses

What a CPA Will Do:

We help our clients stay compliant with contractor tax rules by:

  • Automating W9 collection during onboarding

  • Tracking payments through accounting software

  • Filing 1099s before the IRS deadline

  • Advising on 1099-K thresholds if using payment processors

This is part of our full-service tax compliance model designed for growing businesses with contractor-based teams.

Why Partner with Insogna CPA?

Insogna CPA is more than a CPA firm in Austin, Texas. We’re your trusted financial guide. Ready to help you save money, stay compliant, and make informed business decisions.

What makes us different:

  • Flat-fee pricing (no surprises)

  • Dedicated client support with real-time response

  • Cloud-based systems for modern business owners

  • Comprehensive tax strategy and financial forecasting

  • Expertise in working with self-employed professionals, eCommerce companies, agencies, and real estate investors

Whether you’re looking for tax services near you, help with FBAR filing, or a certified public accountant near you who can think like a CFO, we’re the partner you’ve been looking for.

Let’s Build a Smarter Tax Strategy Together

If you’ve been making any of these mistakes or just wondering whether you are, it’s time to get proactive.

Insogna CPA offers year-round advisory support to help you:

  • Reduce tax liability

  • Stay ahead of IRS deadlines

  • Create a tax-smart growth plan for your business

  • Avoid penalties, confusion, and stress

Schedule your free consultation today, and let’s talk about how to turn your tax strategy into a competitive advantage.

Because tax time shouldn’t feel like panic mode and your accountant should never just be a once-a-year appointment.

..

Michael Harris