Thinking about whether to set up your business as an LLC or a C Corporation? It’s not just about paperwork—it’s about how much you keep in profits, how you pay taxes, and how easy it is to grow your business.
At Insogna CPA, we’ve helped countless businesses across Austin, Round Rock, and surrounding areas figure out the smartest structure for their goals. Whether you’re just getting started or considering a restructure, let’s break it down so you can make a confident, informed decision.
What’s an LLC, and Is It Right for You?
An LLC (Limited Liability Company) is one of the simplest ways to structure a business. It’s flexible, straightforward, and perfect for small businesses looking for liability protection without too much complexity.
What You Get with an LLC:
- Liability Protection: Your personal assets stay safe from business debts and lawsuits.
- Simpler Taxes: LLCs use pass-through taxation, meaning business profits go directly to your personal tax return.
- Flexible Management: No complicated shareholder structure—just you (or you and a partner).
The Catch?
- Self-Employment Taxes: You’ll pay the full 3% self-employment tax on all profits.
- Limited Investment Options: LLCs don’t issue stock, which can make it harder to raise funds.
Example: If your Austin small business earns $100,000 as an LLC, you’ll pay $15,300 in self-employment taxes alone—plus income tax.
What’s a C Corporation, and Is It Right for You?
A C Corporation (C Corp) is a bit more complex but ideal for businesses planning to scale, raise capital, or take on multiple shareholders.
What You Get with a C Corp:
- Easier to Raise Capital: C Corps can issue stock, making it easier to attract investors.
- Liability Protection: Shareholders are shielded from business liabilities.
- Potential Tax Perks: Corporate tax rates may be lower than personal tax rates for certain income levels.
The Catch?
- Double Taxation: Profits are taxed twice—once at the corporate level and again on dividends paid to shareholders.
- More Paperwork: Annual filings, payroll requirements, and strict record-keeping apply.
Example: If your C Corp earns $100,000, it will pay 21% corporate tax ($21,000). If dividends are distributed to shareholders, those earnings could be taxed again on personal returns.
Key Differences Between an LLC and a C Corp (Simplified)
Factor | LLC | C Corporation |
Ownership Flexibility | No shares; flexible management | Share-based ownership with stock |
Taxation | Pass-through to personal taxes | Corporate tax + dividend tax |
Liability Protection | Personal assets protected | Strong liability protection |
Raising Capital | Limited to personal funds or loans | Easier with stock sales |
Compliance Requirements | Minimal paperwork and formalities | Higher reporting and compliance |
Tax Implications: How Each Structure Affects Your Taxes
LLC Taxes (Pass-Through Taxation)
- All profits pass directly to the owner’s personal return.
- Subject to self-employment taxes (15.3%).
For Example:
If your Austin small business earns $80,000 in profit as an LLC, you’ll owe approximately $12,240 in self-employment taxes.
C Corp Taxes (Potential Double Taxation)
- Profits are taxed at the corporate level (21%).
- If dividends are paid, those earnings are taxed again on shareholders’ personal returns.
For Example:
If your C Corp earns $80,000, the company pays $16,800 in corporate tax. If dividends are distributed, shareholders would also pay tax on those payouts.
How to Reduce Taxes?
Working with an experienced Austin CPA firm like Insogna CPA can help you explore strategies like balancing salary vs. dividends to minimize double taxation.
When Should You Choose an LLC?
An LLC is often the better choice if you:
- Own a freelance or consulting
- Want simple tax filing with fewer compliance headaches.
- Don’t plan to seek outside investors.
- Operate a real estate investment
When Should You Choose a C Corporation?
A C Corp makes more sense if you:
- Plan to raise capital from investors or venture capitalists.
- Want to offer stock options to employees.
- Need a structure for multiple shareholders.
- Have long-term plans for scaling or going public.
Real-Life Success Scenario: How We Can Help a Local Business Save on Taxes
The Challenge:
A local marketing agency in Austin, TX wanted to raise capital but was operating as an LLC. They weren’t sure if a C Corp was the right choice due to concerns about double taxation.
The Solution:
Insogna CPA conducts a full tax analysis to determine that switching to a C Corp would better align with their growth goals. We:
- Filed the final LLC return and transitioned the business to a C Corp.
- Implemented a salary and dividend strategy to reduce double taxation.
- Handled all compliance reporting for their Austin-based accounting services.
The Outcome:
- We can successfully raise $500,000 in investor capital.
- Save $10,000 in taxes through optimized dividend strategies.
- Maintain full IRS compliance with minimal stress.
Still Unsure Which Structure Fits Your Business? Let Insogna CPA Help
Deciding between an LLC and a C Corp is more than just a legal choice—it affects your taxes, your growth potential, and your financial security.
At Insogna CPA, we make complex decisions simple. Whether you’re a small business in Austin or planning to expand, we’re here to guide you through:
✅ Clear Tax Comparisons: No confusing jargon—just straight answers.
✅ Simplified Filings: From LLC setup to C Corp tax planning, we handle it all.
✅ Ongoing Compliance: Stay compliant with quarterly and annual reporting.
✅ Maximized Tax Savings: Proven strategies to help you keep more of your profits.
Ready to Find the Best Structure for Your Business?
You don’t need to guess your way through business structures. Let the experts at Insogna CPA, one of the best CPA firms in Austin, walk you through your options with clarity and confidence.
👉 Contact us today for a free consultation!